1st Choice Appliance Repair1st Choice Appliance RepairNashville, TN · Licensed & Insured

Freezer Not Freezing

When the freezer fails but the fridge stays cold — or the reverse — that usually points to airflow, a damper, or a fan rather than the compressor. On a standalone freezer, a failed defrost system or gasket is the most common cause.

Likely causes

When we get a call about a freezer not freezing but fridge is cold, these are the things our technicians check first — roughly in the order of how often each one turns out to be the answer:

  • Evaporator coil iced solid from a failed defrost heater or thermostat
  • Condenser coils blocked with dust, or a failed condenser fan motor
  • Start relay or run capacitor preventing the compressor from starting
  • Door or lid gasket no longer sealing, letting warm humid air in continuously
  • Unit rated for indoor use only, installed in a hot Nashville garage

How we fix it

We diagnose before we quote. That means testing the actual components involved — motors, switches, sensors, valves, and controls — instead of replacing parts in sequence and billing you for the guesses. Once we know what failed, you get the price before we touch anything.

Most freezer repairs of this kind are completed in a single visit, because the parts that cause them are the parts we stock on the van. If yours needs something ordered, we tell you the real timeline up front.

Call (615) 768-0085Freezer Repair

Questions About This Problem

What causes a freezer not freezing but fridge is cold?

When the freezer fails but the fridge stays cold — or the reverse — that usually points to airflow, a damper, or a fan rather than the compressor. On a standalone freezer, a failed defrost system or gasket is the most common cause. The causes we check first are: Evaporator coil iced solid from a failed defrost heater or thermostat; Condenser coils blocked with dust, or a failed condenser fan motor; Start relay or run capacitor preventing the compressor from starting; Door or lid gasket no longer sealing, letting warm humid air in continuously; Unit rated for indoor use only, installed in a hot Nashville garage.

Can I fix this myself or should I call a technician?

Simple checks are fine to do yourself — confirming power at the outlet, checking the breaker, clearing a filter, or looking for something obviously blocking a drain or a vent. Anything involving sealed refrigeration, gas, high-voltage components, or control boards should be diagnosed by a technician. Guessing at parts is how a small repair turns into an expensive one.

How fast can you come out?

Call us and we will book the soonest opening on the schedule, and we tell you an honest arrival window rather than a vague all-day one. Refrigerator and freezer calls get priority because food is on the line.

Other Appliance Problems

Freezer Giving You Trouble?

Call now for a straight answer about what it will take to fix.

(615) 768-0085
Appliance broken?Up-front pricing, fast service
Call now